Welcome to the ultimate guide for an irresistible twist on a beloved classic: Candy Bar S’mores! Forget the campfire and sticky fingers from traditional s’mores for a moment, because we’re about to introduce you to a dessert that’s just as gooey, equally delightful, and incredibly versatile. By simply swapping out the standard chocolate bar for your favorite fun-size candy, this quick and easy recipe elevates the humble s’more into a gourmet treat you can enjoy any time of the year, right from your kitchen broiler.
Imagine perfectly toasted marshmallows melting into a rich peanut butter cup, a crispy Kit Kat, or a chewy caramel chocolate, all sandwiched between crisp graham crackers. This isn’t just a dessert; it’s an experience, a playful indulgence that brings smiles to faces young and old. Whether you’re looking to use up leftover holiday candy, searching for a fast weeknight dessert, or simply craving that nostalgic s’mores goodness without the outdoor fuss, our Candy Bar S’mores are your answer. Get ready to discover a dessert that’s quick, customizable, and guaranteed to be a crowd-pleaser.
Quick Bites: Your Instant Guide to Candy Bar S’mores
- What It Is: A delightful and creative spin on classic s’mores, featuring an array of mini candy bars (like Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, Kit Kats, or Snickers) instead of plain chocolate. These are conveniently broiled indoors for a perfectly gooey, ten-minute dessert that’s perfect for any occasion.
- Why You’ll Love It: This recipe is incredibly fast, simple, and requires minimal cleanup. It’s an ingenious way to repurpose leftover Halloween or holiday candy, transforming it into a fresh, exciting treat. Enjoy the beloved flavors of a campfire s’more anytime, anywhere, without the need for an actual fire.
- How to Make It: Start by arranging graham cracker halves on a baking sheet, then top each with your chosen candy bar and a marshmallow. Broil for less than a minute until golden, carefully flip the marshmallow for even toasting, and broil again briefly. Finally, sandwich with another graham cracker half and prepare for pure indulgence.
For those who consider themselves s’mores purists, the idea of deviating from the classic Hershey’s bar might seem sacrilegious. But we say, let them scoff! More candy bar s’mores for us. It’s truly difficult to maintain any critical stance when your mouth is enveloped in the blissful, gooey sensation of sweet, salty, and intensely satisfying peanut-butter-cup-marshmallow-graham deliciousness. This playful reinvention of the beloved campfire treat opens up a world of flavor possibilities that will convert even the staunchest traditionalists.
One of the most remarkable aspects of this recipe is how effortlessly your broiler transforms into a magical s’mores-making machine. This means you can indulge in this quintessential summertime staple even when the temperatures drop, or whenever a sudden craving strikes and a campfire isn’t an option. It’s a lifesaver for last-minute gatherings, impromptu dessert requests, or simply a cozy night in. The true beauty lies in the freedom to choose your favorite chocolate candy bar, tailoring each s’more to your precise taste. From nutty to caramel-filled, crispy to creamy, the selection is yours, making every batch a special and unique experience. So go ahead, unleash your inner candy connoisseur and prepare for a dessert that’s nothing short of extraordinary. –Molly Gilbert
Why Our Testers Raved About These Candy Bar S’mores
The overwhelming factor that captivated our recipe testers was the sheer speed and ease with which these delightful treats came together. In a mere ten minutes, tops, a decadent dessert appeared as if by magic. Beyond the impressive quickness, our testers also adored the boundless opportunities for customization and creative improvisation. Sarah Heend, one of our testers, enthusiastically highlighted the “warm, soft marshmallows and chocolate” that perfectly satiated her sweet cravings, transforming ordinary candy into an extraordinary dessert. This swift satisfaction, combined with the joy of personalizing each s’more, made this recipe an instant favorite among our team, proving that sometimes the simplest twists yield the most memorable results.
Frequently Asked Questions About S’mores
While the exact origins of s’mores are shrouded in a bit of delightful mystery, the first known recorded recipe for this iconic campfire treat appeared under the name “Some Mores” in the 1927 publication “Tramping and Trailing with the Girl Scouts.” This early recipe, a testament to its enduring appeal, called for a generous sixteen graham crackers, sixteen marshmallows, and eight classic Hershey’s chocolate bars. From that moment on, this simple yet magical combination of ingredients cemented its place in culinary history, evolving into the beloved dessert we cherish today.
For classic, traditional s’mores, Hershey’s milk chocolate bars have long reigned supreme as the undisputed go-to choice. Their specific size and meltability are perfectly suited for the job. However, when it comes to this quick, indoor-broiler version, our dedicated recipe testers have ventured beyond tradition and wholeheartedly approved a wider, more exciting range of chocolate options. Their top recommendations include luscious peanut butter cups, delightful chocolate-coated coconut bars, refreshing chocolate-covered peppermint patties, and even versatile leftover Christmas almond bark. The wonderful truth is, almost any chocolate you fancy will melt beautifully and contribute to a fantastic s’more experience, offering endless possibilities for flavor exploration.
Absolutely! While graham crackers are the traditional foundation for s’mores, there are plenty of inventive ways to “gussy up” or personalize your treat by exploring alternative bases. You can pay homage to the treat’s origins by utilizing your favorite Girl Scout cookies, adding a unique flavor and texture profile. For an unexpected savory-sweet crunch, thick, wavy potato chips are an adventurous and surprisingly delicious option. Other excellent choices include subtly spiced speculoos cookies, zesty gingersnaps, or rich and chewy molasses cookies. These alternatives allow you to infuse your s’mores with diverse flavors and textures, making each bite an exciting discovery.
Share Your Sweet Success: Write a Review!
If you whip up this delightful Candy Bar S’mores recipe, or any other dish from Leite’s Culinaria, we’d absolutely love to hear from you! Please consider leaving a review, a star rating, and even sharing your best photo in the comments section below. Your feedback and culinary creations truly brighten our day. –David
Candy Bar S’mores: The Ultimate Indoor Treat
David Leite
Ingredients for 12 Irresistible S’mores
- 12 graham crackers, broken into 24 squares (one graham cracker yields two squares for assembly)
- 12 pieces “fun-size” chocolate candy bars, such as mini Kit Kats, Almond Joys, Snickers, Twix, or regular-size Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. Feel free to mix and match!
- 12 large marshmallows (ensure they are fresh for best melting and toasting results)
Step-by-Step Instructions to Heavenly S’mores
-
Begin by preheating your broiler. Position an oven rack approximately 4 inches from the heat source. For the easiest cleanup, line a sturdy baking sheet with aluminum foil or parchment paper; this will catch any drips from the melting marshmallows and chocolate, making post-dessert tidying a breeze.
-
Carefully place half of your graham cracker squares onto the prepared baking sheet. On top of each graham cracker square, artfully arrange one of your chosen fun-size candy bars. The variety of candy bars is where the fun truly begins, so feel free to mix and match! Finally, gently place a large marshmallow directly on top of each candy bar, ensuring it sits securely.
-
With extreme caution, slide the baking sheet onto the preheated oven rack. It is absolutely crucial to keep the oven door ajar and maintain a vigilant watch over your s’mores. Broiling is an intense, fast-acting heat source, and marshmallows can go from perfectly golden to burnt in a matter of seconds. Depending on your oven’s broiler strength, this initial toasting can take as little as 20 to 30 seconds. Look for a beautiful, golden-brown hue on the marshmallow tops.
-
Promptly remove the baking sheet from the oven. Using a pair of kitchen tongs, carefully grasp each marshmallow from the side and gently flip it over. This ensures the previously uncooked side now faces upwards, allowing for an even and deliciously toasted finish. Return the baking sheet to the broiler, again keeping a very close eye, and broil for another 20 seconds or so, until the second side of each marshmallow achieves that desirable good and toasty caramelization. The chocolate underneath should be delightfully melted and gooey by now.
-
Remove the baking sheet from the oven for the final time. Without delay, gently place one of the remaining graham cracker squares on top of each toasted marshmallow. Press down ever-so-gently until the s’mores adhere, creating a perfect sandwich. The warm, melted components will quickly bind together. Now, what are you waiting for?! These warm, gooey, personalized candy bar s’mores are best enjoyed immediately. Serve them up and revel in the instant gratification!
Adapted From
Sheet Pan Suppers
Discover More on Amazon
Nutrition Information
Please note: Nutrition information is automatically calculated and should be considered an approximation. Individual results may vary based on ingredients used.
Insights from Our Recipe Testers
Elsa M. Jacobson
The “choose-your-own-adventure” approach to these s’mores immediately sparked my imagination, prompting dreams of a rich dark chocolate and marshmallow fusion. I eagerly experimented with both a dark chocolate peanut butter cup and a simple piece of dark chocolate almond bark, and both yielded incredibly satisfying results.
Now, I’m absolutely captivated by the endless possibilities! I’m envisioning a Mounds bar variation – do they still make those delightful coconut-filled bars?! Or perhaps a dark chocolate Snickers for that perfect blend of caramel, nougat, and peanuts? My next quest will definitely involve dark chocolate-dipped dried pineapple. Honestly, the potential for personalizing these s’mores is truly limitless, making them a consistently exciting treat to prepare.
I did find that the process of flipping the marshmallow mid-broil was a tad tricky, and not always perfectly executed. However, it ultimately didn’t detract from the enjoyment, as everything gets wonderfully squished together between the graham crackers anyway! This is definitely a dessert meant for immediate gratification – its delightful gooeyness means it’s not a candidate for keeping or making ahead.
P.S. While the recipe suggests “Serves 12,” implying one s’more per person, I must confess that with so many tantalizing candy options to explore, a single s’more feels a little on the skimpy side. You’ll likely want more than one!
Sarah Heend
This candy bar s’mores recipe was an absolute lifesaver on a chilly Thursday evening. We needed a quick, comforting dessert but certainly weren’t in the mood to pull out a multitude of mixing bowls or embark on an elaborate baking project.
Fortuitously, we had just enough graham crackers for two s’mores – one for me and one for my son. Our pantry also harbored two rather forlorn, slightly aged marshmallows, tucked away in the back. The real treasure, however, was a collection of leftover Christmas candy and a few chocolates from an early Valentine’s Day gift. It was the perfect opportunity for a sweet scavenger hunt!
We fired up the broiler, and in under 10 minutes, magic happened. We were rewarded with warm, incredibly soft marshmallows and perfectly melted chocolate that effortlessly calmed our sweet cravings. Not a bad outcome for what essentially started as pantry dregs! It truly felt like a little victory.
Admittedly, we did miss the deeply toasted, almost caramel-like notes that only a true fire-roasted marshmallow can deliver. However, for the middle of winter, these indoor s’mores certainly hit the spot and satisfied our craving beautifully. They proved to be a wonderfully comforting substitute.
In terms of timing, the marshmallows required about 30 seconds per side under our broiler to develop a lovely hint of golden color. I opted for a mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup, and the results were spectacular – both the peanut butter and the chocolate became wonderfully warm and gooey in the oven, creating a luscious texture.
My son, ever the adventurous eater, chose a Peppermint Patty. While I initially questioned the mint and marshmallow combination, he was absolutely thrilled with his choice! This just goes to show how adaptable and personalizable these s’mores are.
The tongs worked exceptionally well for turning the marshmallows; the tops were gloriously gooey, yet the sides remained intact. A crucial tip for anyone attempting this: maintain a very close watch on everything. My marshmallows began to emit a slight wisp of smoke even before they were deeply browned. I promptly removed them at that point, as I imagine they could transition from lightly toasted to completely charred in mere seconds. Vigilance is key to s’mores success!